{"meta":{"title":"Democracys Score v1.0 Beta","methodVersion":"1.0-beta","source":"V-Dem Country-Year Core v16","sourceUrl":"https://www.v-dem.net/media/datasets/V-Dem-CY-Core-v16_csv.zip","sourceZipSha256":"9055455c4adacd1ad9e78f1a7f3ac0768bdf26992e7651c0602a43ca7bdd4506","sourceDoi":"https://doi.org/10.23696/vdemds26","sourcePublished":"2026-03","observationYears":[1900,2025],"generated":"2026-09-03","license":"CC BY-SA 4.0","weights":{"electoral":0.2,"liberal":0.2,"participatory":0.2,"deliberative":0.2,"egalitarian":0.2},"formula":"100 × (0.5 × weighted arithmetic mean + 0.5 × weighted geometric mean)","countryCount":179,"observationCount":19215},"country":{"id":121,"code":"KAZ","cowCode":705,"name":"Kazakhstan","slug":"kazakhstan","history":[{"year":1990,"score":35.4,"lower":27.4,"upper":41.9,"electoral":24.7,"liberal":40.2,"participatory":15.3,"deliberative":48.0,"egalitarian":58.1},{"year":1991,"score":36.0,"lower":27.7,"upper":42.8,"electoral":28.9,"liberal":42.0,"participatory":15.3,"deliberative":44.9,"egalitarian":57.2},{"year":1992,"score":37.6,"lower":29.7,"upper":45.2,"electoral":30.3,"liberal":43.1,"participatory":19.1,"deliberative":44.9,"egalitarian":57.0},{"year":1993,"score":38.8,"lower":30.6,"upper":45.8,"electoral":30.2,"liberal":44.0,"participatory":21.8,"deliberative":44.9,"egalitarian":58.6},{"year":1994,"score":36.2,"lower":28.2,"upper":43.2,"electoral":30.3,"liberal":42.6,"participatory":19.6,"deliberative":35.8,"egalitarian":58.6},{"year":1995,"score":35.2,"lower":28.2,"upper":42.4,"electoral":28.8,"liberal":34.7,"participatory":26.0,"deliberative":35.8,"egalitarian":53.6},{"year":1996,"score":32.4,"lower":25.3,"upper":38.9,"electoral":28.3,"liberal":30.8,"participatory":21.2,"deliberative":32.4,"egalitarian":53.1},{"year":1997,"score":30.5,"lower":22.9,"upper":36.3,"electoral":29.5,"liberal":31.0,"participatory":21.2,"deliberative":23.4,"egalitarian":51.0},{"year":1998,"score":29.6,"lower":22.2,"upper":35.2,"electoral":28.4,"liberal":31.0,"participatory":22.7,"deliberative":19.4,"egalitarian":50.4},{"year":1999,"score":29.3,"lower":22.2,"upper":34.9,"electoral":26.8,"liberal":30.9,"participatory":22.7,"deliberative":19.7,"egalitarian":50.4},{"year":2000,"score":30.3,"lower":23.2,"upper":36.4,"electoral":27.0,"liberal":31.1,"participatory":20.6,"deliberative":25.8,"egalitarian":50.4},{"year":2001,"score":29.3,"lower":22.3,"upper":35.2,"electoral":25.5,"liberal":31.1,"participatory":20.3,"deliberative":23.0,"egalitarian":50.4},{"year":2002,"score":28.5,"lower":21.2,"upper":34.0,"electoral":25.2,"liberal":31.5,"participatory":19.9,"deliberative":19.2,"egalitarian":51.6},{"year":2003,"score":28.9,"lower":22.0,"upper":34.5,"electoral":24.7,"liberal":30.5,"participatory":19.6,"deliberative":22.7,"egalitarian":51.6},{"year":2004,"score":30.1,"lower":23.2,"upper":36.1,"electoral":24.6,"liberal":31.0,"participatory":19.2,"deliberative":28.4,"egalitarian":51.6},{"year":2005,"score":29.9,"lower":22.8,"upper":35.7,"electoral":23.9,"liberal":31.0,"participatory":18.9,"deliberative":28.4,"egalitarian":51.6},{"year":2006,"score":29.5,"lower":22.5,"upper":35.4,"electoral":24.2,"liberal":31.0,"participatory":18.5,"deliberative":26.9,"egalitarian":51.3},{"year":2007,"score":29.2,"lower":22.3,"upper":35.0,"electoral":24.0,"liberal":31.6,"participatory":17.7,"deliberative":26.2,"egalitarian":51.3},{"year":2008,"score":29.1,"lower":22.1,"upper":34.7,"electoral":24.1,"liberal":31.6,"participatory":17.4,"deliberative":25.7,"egalitarian":51.3},{"year":2009,"score":29.2,"lower":22.5,"upper":35.1,"electoral":24.2,"liberal":31.6,"participatory":17.0,"deliberative":26.8,"egalitarian":51.3},{"year":2010,"score":29.4,"lower":22.5,"upper":35.5,"electoral":23.6,"liberal":31.6,"participatory":16.8,"deliberative":29.3,"egalitarian":50.8},{"year":2011,"score":29.0,"lower":22.0,"upper":35.0,"electoral":23.3,"liberal":31.2,"participatory":16.4,"deliberative":28.6,"egalitarian":50.5},{"year":2012,"score":28.6,"lower":21.7,"upper":34.5,"electoral":23.2,"liberal":29.2,"participatory":16.1,"deliberative":28.9,"egalitarian":50.5},{"year":2013,"score":28.3,"lower":21.2,"upper":34.1,"electoral":22.9,"liberal":28.2,"participatory":16.0,"deliberative":28.2,"egalitarian":51.2},{"year":2014,"score":28.3,"lower":20.9,"upper":34.0,"electoral":23.0,"liberal":28.3,"participatory":15.7,"deliberative":28.2,"egalitarian":51.5},{"year":2015,"score":28.2,"lower":21.0,"upper":33.8,"electoral":23.4,"liberal":28.0,"participatory":15.7,"deliberative":28.2,"egalitarian":50.6},{"year":2016,"score":29.1,"lower":21.9,"upper":35.1,"electoral":24.2,"liberal":28.8,"participatory":16.5,"deliberative":29.9,"egalitarian":51.0},{"year":2017,"score":28.5,"lower":21.6,"upper":34.6,"electoral":23.5,"liberal":28.6,"participatory":14.6,"deliberative":28.9,"egalitarian":52.8},{"year":2018,"score":27.9,"lower":20.9,"upper":34.2,"electoral":23.2,"liberal":27.5,"participatory":15.9,"deliberative":28.0,"egalitarian":50.1},{"year":2019,"score":30.7,"lower":23.4,"upper":37.1,"electoral":23.6,"liberal":29.1,"participatory":15.9,"deliberative":39.8,"egalitarian":51.3},{"year":2020,"score":32.5,"lower":25.1,"upper":39.0,"electoral":24.1,"liberal":29.8,"participatory":17.2,"deliberative":43.5,"egalitarian":54.9},{"year":2021,"score":33.2,"lower":26.0,"upper":40.1,"electoral":25.3,"liberal":30.1,"participatory":20.1,"deliberative":42.5,"egalitarian":53.1},{"year":2022,"score":37.5,"lower":30.7,"upper":45.0,"electoral":26.5,"liberal":33.1,"participatory":25.3,"deliberative":51.5,"egalitarian":56.3},{"year":2023,"score":37.9,"lower":30.4,"upper":45.2,"electoral":26.9,"liberal":34.4,"participatory":29.3,"deliberative":48.2,"egalitarian":54.6},{"year":2024,"score":38.0,"lower":30.0,"upper":44.9,"electoral":26.7,"liberal":32.2,"participatory":29.3,"deliberative":50.5,"egalitarian":55.4},{"year":2025,"score":36.9,"lower":29.3,"upper":43.9,"electoral":25.9,"liberal":32.6,"participatory":24.6,"deliberative":50.5,"egalitarian":56.5}],"firstYear":1990,"lastYear":2025,"latest":{"year":2025,"score":36.9,"lower":29.3,"upper":43.9,"electoral":25.9,"liberal":32.6,"participatory":24.6,"deliberative":50.5,"egalitarian":56.5},"rank":127,"totalRanked":179,"weakest":"participatory","changes":{"1":-1.1,"5":4.4,"10":8.7,"25":6.6}}}